Best Rivalry Outside Hockey? Dodgers-Giants

Published on 24-Sep-2014 by J Square Humboldt
MLB / MLB Daily Update

No bats were harmed in the making of this argument.

Traditional clashes are standard headline material in sports.

Destination games.

Yankees-Red Sox. Auburn-Alabama. Cardinals-Cubs. Packers-Bears. USC-Nôtre Dame. And so on.

The NBA? Whoever's trendy vs Whomever's hot. Roster dependent.

The NHL? Different category. How can rivalries in other sports be compared to those where dropping the gloves is part of the game? Intensity is second only to oxygen -- barely -- in those arenas. So that's a different level of discourse.

Pucks aside, then, for sheer animosity in the midst of competition, nothing beats the San Francisco Giants and Los Angeles Dodgers.

They proved it again last night. Frustrated by watching the Bums pull away in the NL West but still caught in a tight wild card race, Giant ace Madison Bumgarner couldn't resist the temptation of dropping a hint:

If Hong Sung-Heon ever leaves South Korea's Doosan Bears for either one of these teams, it will stagger the imagination.

Giants-Dodgers -- or in some quarters, Dodgers-Giants; it makes a difference -- rekindles crazy memories, such as:

  • In 1890, Brooklyn third-base coach Darby O'Brien pretended to be a base runner and broke for home, drawing a throw and allowing the actual Dodger runner to make it safely to third.
  • In 1910, Giants 3B Art Devlin charged the stands and punched a Dodger fan unconscious for heckling him, triggering a Giants players vs Dodger fans brawl that resulted in Devlin being arrested for assault.
  • In 1946, when Dodger skipper Leo Durocher inspired the infamous Nice guys finish last quotation, he was referring to Giants manager Mel Ott.
  • In 1968, Dick Dietz took a heater to the elbow with the bases loaded, never budging, in an attempt to break Don Drysdale's run at the record for consecutive scoreless innings.

Far and away, the ugliest incident in baseball history happened in 1965, when Giants' legend Juan Marichal took a bat to Dodger catcher John Roseboro's head, opening a two-inch gash.

Marichal and Roseboro

None other than Sandy Koufax -- that's him coming to Roseboro's aid in the left photo -- was the pitcher who dusted Marichal and triggered the melée.

Rationality went out the window last night when Puig shot a menacing stare at Bumgarner after being clipped. It was a 1-2 cutter. Where's the malice in a 1-2 secondary pitch? That was nothing more than a calling card. This is where the Chewbacca Defense kicks in:

Bumgarner said as much afterward:

He’ll know if it’s on purpose, which that one wasn’t. I’ll make sure of that.

Who would expect less from a Giants-Dodgers game? Or a Dodgers-Giants game?

Table 'dailypla_database.metrics_robots' doesn't exist